Are Ryzen i5 i7 i9 public CPUs suitable for servers?
Thread | |
---|---|
![]() 🎨 Creator 📖 Posts: 173 ↩️ Replies: 79 ❤️ Reactions: 25 |
Norda Scripts
Posted 1741821420 (Edited) (92 views)Thread in the french forum > Fr 🇫🇷 here : https://osgmod.com/fr/forum/aide-et-entraire-gmod-glua-lua/les-cpu-public-ryzen-i5-i7-i9-sontils-adaptes-aux-serveurs/page-1
Are Ryzen i5 i7 i9 public CPUs suitable for servers? Contents
1. Introduction Today, many hosting providers, in a bid to cut costs while attracting new customers, are promoting servers equipped with mainstream processors, such as Ryzen 9, i7 or i9. These are often presented as offering superior performance to traditional server processors, such as Intel Xeon or AMD EPYC, with the argument of “raw power” at lower cost. However, this promise of exceptional performance is often accompanied by shortcuts that are not immediately apparent.
2. Differences between consumer CPUs and server CPUs Server CPUs, such as Intel Xeon and AMD EPYC, are specifically designed to operate in mission-critical environments, where stability and reliability are paramount. Consumer CPUs, on the other hand, are primarily optimized for personal use, such as gaming or office applications. Key differences between these two types of processors include:
3. Performance: Single-core vs. multi-core Some games and applications, such as Gmod, are optimized for single-core performance, which can give the impression that a consumer CPU is faster. However, in a server environment, the reality is quite different:
4. Reliability and long-term stability A server needs to operate without interruption for years, sometimes in demanding environments. Unlike consumer CPUs, server processors are specifically designed to guarantee long-term reliability and stability. Here are their key benefits:
5. Virtualization and memory management Server CPUs offer advanced features for virtualization, such as:
6. Scalability and compatibility A server must be able to evolve. Server CPUs :
7. Why do some hosts use mainstream CPUs? Some hosters choose to use mainstream processors like Ryzen or i9 in order to cut costs while promoting high performance. Here's why:
8. Energy consumption and cooling Server CPUs are optimized to consume less energy per core while remaining stable.
9. Security and fault management Server CPUs feature advanced security functions:
10. Response to the “different use case” argument Some defend the use of mainstream processors, arguing that it all depends on the use case, and that these CPUs may be suitable in certain situations. It's true that not all servers have the same requirements, but that doesn't mean that a mainstream CPU is an appropriate choice for serious hosting. Why?
11. Is it possible to use a Ryzen 9, i7 or i9 on a Bare Metal server? Yes, it's technically possible to use a Ryzen 9, i7 or i9 on a Bare Metal server, but it's not ideal for serious hosting. A Bare Metal server is supposed to offer stable performance and high availability, which requires hardware designed to run 24/7 under constant load.
12. Conclusion Hosting a small game server on a Ryzen or i9 may work in some cases. However, for a serious host operating on a large scale, server processors such as Xeon or EPYC remain the best option, guaranteeing stability, longevity and performance management suited to continuous loads.
😋 |
Replies | |
---|---|
![]() 🎨 Creator 📖 Posts: 173 ↩️ Replies: 79 ❤️ Reactions: 25 |
Norda Scripts Posted 1741822084💬 Any questions or opinions on the subject? Feel free to react in comments and share your experience! |
![]() 💙 Customer 📖 Posts: 0 ↩️ Replies: 1 ❤️ Reactions: 0 |
☿ Purple Posted 1741855295Hello! Absolutely!
You are correct, and I’d like to highlight a few points worth considering (not errors or rebuttals, as you are 100% right). There is nothing wrong with using consumer-grade hardware for servers, especially for game servers. Today's CPUs rely heavily on multithreading (SMT/HT), particularly in consumer-grade models. The main drawback of using a desktop CPU instead of a server CPU is usually the core count and the socket compatibility needed for dual or quad-core setups. Interestingly, the performance of a single core/thread in a server environment does not always match that of a desktop environment. It’s a bit of a pet peeve of mine to mention this because I generally want to emphasize that the workstation/server industry is superior to the desktop industry concerning performance. For serious hosting, I completely agree. In the backend of many companies I have worked with, we utilized E5-2660 V4 CPUs in a virtual environment, which performed brilliantly. However, PCIe lanes have never been a significant issue for servers. In most cases, even smaller cabinet-mounted servers come with a RAID controller that can support a 10-gig card or whatever else is needed. Consumer CPUs typically have enough lanes to handle these configurations. For instance, I've been using a Ryzen 9 7900 in my server, and it has maintained its boost clock for months without experiencing any performance loss. Power and heat are not concerns; the 65W TDP of that CPU significantly outperforms my home server, which consumes about 205W of power. I also use 2 E5-2697 V2 CPUs in my home lab, currently set up as a virtual environment for gaming and general desktop use. Regarding ECC memory, I completely agree that it is essential. In the realm of gaming, desktop CPUs often host the server and handle all necessary calculations, a practice game studios have leveraged for years. Personally, I’ve used desktop CPUs in my servers for over six years, transitioning from an Intel i9-9900K to a Ryzen 9 5950X, and now to a Ryzen 9 7900. The only issues I’ve encountered have been related to user error and the games themselves. I would absolutely love to have a chat with you about this! Coffee and IT make for a perfect conversation. We could discuss our experiences and hopefully come up with solutions for the community as a whole. I completely agree with your perspective, and it's a personal burden for me as well. I'm eager to start my own hosting company, and navigating the price-to-performance challenge in the Software as a Service industry is a significant hurdle I want to overcome. Cheers! | Warren ~ Purple |
Sign in or register to reply